How to choose a web designer
What to look for when choosing a web designer, from checking past work and communication to who does the work and what follows launch.
Choosing a web designer is less about finding the most talented person and more about finding someone whose work suits your business and who will still answer your emails in two years. Most designers can make a site look good. The differences that matter show up in how they communicate, who actually does the work, and what happens once the site is live.
Here is how we would go about it if we were on your side of the table.
Look at past work properly
A portfolio of screenshots tells you very little. Ask for links to live sites and open them on your phone, since that is how most of your customers will see yours.
As you look, ask yourself:
- Does it load quickly?
- Within five seconds, can I tell what the business does and how to contact it?
- Do the sites look different from one another, or is it one template in different colours?
- Are any of them for businesses about my size?
- Do the sites look cared for, or are there broken pages and notices from three years ago?
- Is the writing clear, or is it filler?
Then ask to speak with a past client or two. Useful questions for them: Did it finish on time and on budget? What happened when something went wrong? How quickly do they respond now? Would you hire them again?
Treat the sales conversation as a preview
How a designer behaves before you sign is the best they will ever behave. If replies are slow and vague now, they will not improve once you have paid a deposit.
Good signs:
- They reply within a day or so
- They explain things in plain words and check you have understood
- They ask about your customers, your best jobs and what you want the site to achieve
- They occasionally disagree with you, and say why
- They send a written proposal that is easy to follow
Be a little wary of someone who says yes to everything. A designer who asks "why do you want a slideshow?" is doing their job.
Find out who does the work
"We" can mean many things. There are three common setups, each with trade-offs.
A freelancer. You deal directly with the person making the site, which is efficient and personal. The risk is that one person can get sick, go on holiday or become overbooked.
A small studio. A few people with different skills who cover for each other. Usually a good balance for small businesses.
A larger agency. More process, more specialists, and typically a higher price. You may deal with an account manager and never meet the person building the site.
Some designers pass parts of the job to contractors, locally or overseas. That is not automatically a problem, but you should know. Ask directly: who designs it, who builds it, who writes the words, and who do I talk to?
That third question deserves attention. Projects stall on content more than anything else. If you are expected to write every page and supply every photo, be honest with yourself about whether you will. If not, choose someone who offers writing help.
Ask what happens after launch
A website is not finished on launch day. It needs hosting, security updates, backups, the odd repair, and changes as your business changes. Find out who does that and what it costs.
The usual arrangements are:
- A one-off build, after which you look after it yourself or find someone who will
- A build plus an optional care plan
- A monthly subscription that covers the build, hosting and ongoing changes
None of these is wrong. What matters is that you know which one you are buying.
Ownership needs to be settled in writing before you start:
- The domain name should be registered in your name, with a login you hold
- You should know who owns the design, the text and the photos
- You should know what you can take with you if you part ways, and in what form
Compare what is included, not only the total
Quotes for what sounds like the same website can vary enormously. Usually the difference is in what is included. Line them up and check each for the number of pages, writing, photography, rounds of revisions, basic search setup, training and aftercare.
The cheapest quote often costs more over a few years, once the extras and repairs are added. The dearest is not necessarily better for a small, simple site.
A few things should make you step back:
- A guarantee of top Google rankings
- Pressure to sign today for a special price
- No written scope or contract
- Reluctance to show live sites or put you in touch with past clients
- Insistence on registering your domain in their name
A simple way to shortlist
- Write down your website's main job and your rough budget.
- Ask two or three business owners whose sites you like who built them.
- Pick three candidates and check their live work on your phone.
- Have a half-hour conversation with each.
- Compare the written proposals line by line.
- Phone one past client of your preferred choice.
- Choose the one you would feel comfortable ringing with a basic question.
That last test sounds soft, but it is the one we trust most. A designer you hesitate to call is the wrong designer.