Foldwren

Duplicate content: what it is and when it matters

Learn what duplicate content is, its common causes, how to handle supplier descriptions and location pages, and when it is worth fixing.

Duplicate content is the same, or nearly the same, text appearing at more than one web address. It might be within your own site or shared between your site and someone else's.

It has a fearsome reputation it mostly does not deserve. For the ordinary kinds that turn up on small business sites, the realistic consequence is wasted effort, not punishment. Knowing which kinds matter saves a lot of unnecessary worry.

Is there a penalty for duplicate content?

In the ordinary case, no. Google has said for years that there is no penalty simply for having some duplicated text. A great deal of the web is repeated: quotes, product specifications, legal boilerplate, addresses.

What happens instead is filtering. When a search engine finds several pages with the same content, it generally picks one to show and sets the others aside. That creates three practical problems.

  • The version chosen may not be the one you wanted.
  • Your signals get split. If links are spread across four copies of a page, none is as strong as one combined page would be.
  • You do not stand out. If your page says exactly what fifty other sites say, there is little reason to show yours.

The exception is deliberate manipulation: copying other sites wholesale, or generating masses of near identical pages purely to catch searches. That can lead to real action against a site. It is a different thing from accidentally having two addresses for your contact page.

What causes it by accident?

Most duplication on small sites is technical and unintended.

  • Several versions of your address. With and without "www", or secure and non secure, all showing the same site.
  • Tracking and filter parameters. Extra bits added to an address by sorting, filtering or campaign tracking, each creating a "new" page with the same content.
  • One product in several categories, reachable at a different address through each.
  • Print friendly or PDF versions of pages.
  • A test copy of the site left visible to search engines.
  • Tag and archive pages on a blog that repeat the full text of posts.

These are usually solved once, in the site's settings, by whoever builds or hosts it.

What about supplier product descriptions?

This is the big one for online shops. A manufacturer supplies a description, and every retailer pastes it in. A hundred shops end up with word for word identical product pages.

It is not against any rule. It simply gives a search engine no reason to prefer your page over the manufacturer's or a large retailer's.

You probably cannot rewrite a thousand products, and you do not need to. Prioritise.

  1. Pick your best sellers and highest margin items.
  2. Write your own description for each, in your own voice.
  3. Add what the supplier text leaves out: who it suits, how it compares with similar items, sizing advice, what customers ask about it.
  4. Use your own photos where you can.
  5. Leave the specification list as supplied. Facts are facts.

Say you run a homewares shop selling a popular cast iron pot. The supplier text lists dimensions and materials. Yours can add that it fits a whole chicken, is heavy to lift when full, works on induction, and which size most of your customers choose for a family of four. That is useful, and it is yours alone.

What about location pages?

Service businesses hit this when they want to appear in several suburbs or towns. The tempting shortcut is one page copied thirty times with only the place name changed.

Search engines recognise that pattern easily. Pages like this are sometimes called doorway pages, and they are specifically discouraged. At best most of them are ignored.

A location page earns its place when it holds something particular to that location:

  • Work you have done there, with photos
  • Details relevant to the area: housing types, common problems, local rules you deal with
  • How far you travel and any call out arrangements for that area
  • Reviews from customers in that area

If you cannot write a few true, specific paragraphs about an area, it probably does not need its own page. List it on a general service area page instead. Five real pages will serve you better than thirty hollow ones.

What should you do about it?

A short list of fixes, roughly in order.

  1. Settle on one version of your site address and redirect the others to it. Any competent host or developer will have done this, but check.
  2. Use canonical tags. These are behind the scenes labels that tell search engines which address is the main version of a page. Most platforms add them automatically.
  3. Keep test sites private, behind a password or blocked from indexing.
  4. Merge pages that overlap. Two thin pages on the same topic should become one good page, with the old address redirected.
  5. Rewrite what matters. Your key product and service pages should be in your own words.
  6. Make location pages earn their keep, or remove them.
  7. Check Google Search Console. Its indexing report lists pages treated as duplicates and which version was chosen. Most entries there are harmless. Look for important pages where the wrong version was picked.

Then stop worrying about it. A repeated footer, a shared disclaimer, or a paragraph that appears on two pages is not a problem. Duplicate content matters when it leaves your important pages with nothing to distinguish them, and the cure for that is writing something worth choosing.

Your order