Foldwren

Icons and illustrations: when to use them on a website

How to tell when icons and illustrations make a website clearer, how to keep their style consistent, and why icons need text labels.

Icons and illustrations belong on a website when they help someone understand something faster. When they are there to fill a gap or make a section look "designed", they add clutter and very little else.

That is the whole test, and it is stricter than it sounds. A lot of the icons on small business websites would not survive it.

When an icon helps

An icon is useful when it speeds up recognition. People spot a familiar shape faster than they read a word, so a good icon acts as a signpost.

Icons that do real work:

  • Contact details. A phone, an envelope and a map pin beside your number, email and address. Everyone knows these.
  • Common actions. A magnifying glass for search, a cart for shopping, a cross to close, an arrow for "next".
  • Scannable lists. A small icon beside each item in a list of services or features gives the eye something to catch on, as long as each icon actually relates to its item.
  • Practical information. Wheelchair access, parking, wifi, dog friendly, card payments. These suit a cafe or venue page well.

In all of these, the icon stands for something concrete that most people have seen represented that way many times before.

When it is only decoration

The trouble starts when icons are asked to represent ideas.

You have seen the pattern. Three icons in a row beneath a heading such as "Why choose us": a handshake above "Integrity", a medal above "Quality", a lightbulb above "Innovation". The icons add no information, and the words beneath them are nearly as empty. It is a layout that exists because the template had three boxes to fill.

Other signs an icon is decoration:

  • You chose it after the text was written, by searching for "something that looks like trust".
  • Remove it and nothing becomes harder to understand.
  • Different people guess different meanings for it.

A little decoration is no crime. But decoration costs attention, and on a small screen it costs space. If a section needs enlivening, a real photo or a specific fact will nearly always do more than an icon of a rocket.

Always pair icons with labels

Very few icons are understood by everyone. The phone, the envelope, the house, the magnifying glass, the cart and not many more. Beyond that short list, an icon alone is a guessing game.

Think of a row of unlabelled symbols in an app you have just installed. Is the heart "favourites" or "health"? Is the clock "history" or "opening hours"? You find out by tapping and hoping. Your customers shouldn't have to do that on your website.

So our rule is simple: every icon gets a text label, visible at all times.

  • A label that appears only on hover doesn't count, because there is no hover on a phone.
  • The three line menu icon is widely recognised, yet adding the word "Menu" still helps, especially for older visitors.

Labels matter for accessibility too. Someone using a screen reader can't see the icon. An icon that works as a button needs a text name in the code, and purely decorative icons should be hidden from screen readers so they aren't announced as noise. Ask your designer to confirm both.

Keep the style consistent

Mixed icon styles are one of the quickest ways to make a site look amateur. It happens when icons are gathered one at a time from different sources.

For a set to look like a set, the icons should share:

  • The same construction. All outlined or all filled, never a mix.
  • The same line thickness.
  • The same corner style. Rounded or sharp.
  • The same size and spacing.
  • The same colours. Usually one colour from your palette. Multicoloured icons draw too much attention.
  • The same level of detail. A simple envelope looks odd beside an intricate drawing of a van.

The practical answer is to choose one icon family and take everything from it. If the set lacks an icon you need, pick the closest match from the same family before reaching for a different one.

Where illustrations fit

Illustrations are bigger and more expressive than icons, and they suit particular jobs.

Good uses:

  • Explaining a process. A simple diagram of how your service works, or how a product fits together.
  • Showing what can't be photographed. Software, financial services, anything abstract or confidential.
  • Setting a tone. Hand drawn illustrations can make a childcare centre, a vet or a cafe feel warm and distinctive.
  • Maps. A drawn map of your service area or how to find the cellar door.

Poor uses:

  • Replacing photos of real work. A builder, florist or groomer should show the actual results. A drawing of a house is no substitute for a photo of one you built.
  • Generic stock illustration. The flat cartoon people with tiny heads and long limbs have appeared on so many sites that they now read as filler, much like the stock photo handshake.

A quick check for your own site

Go through your main pages and ask of each icon or illustration:

  1. Does it help someone understand or find something faster?
  2. Would its meaning be clear to a first time visitor?
  3. Does it have a visible text label?
  4. Does it match the style of every other icon on the site?
  5. Is it smaller and quieter than the content it supports?
  6. If it vanished, would anyone notice?

Remove whatever fails the first and last questions. Label whatever fails the third. Most sites end up with fewer icons, each doing a clear job, and the pages look better for it.

Your order