Foldwren

Writing a returns policy that builds confidence

How to write a clear, fair returns policy for an Australian store, separating change of mind returns from faulty goods and consumer guarantees.

A returns policy is read at two moments: just before someone buys from you for the first time, and just after something has gone wrong. In both cases the reader is slightly nervous. A good policy calms them down. A bad one, full of capital letters and "NO REFUNDS", confirms their worst suspicion about buying from a small shop online.

You can write a policy that protects your business and still sounds like a reasonable person wrote it. The key is understanding that there are two quite different situations to cover.

Two situations, two sets of rules

Change of mind. The product is fine, but the customer picked the wrong size, had second thoughts or received it as a gift they did not want. In general terms, Australian law does not require you to accept these returns. Whether you do, and on what conditions, is your choice.

Something is wrong with the product. It is faulty, damaged, not as described or does not do what it should. Here the customer has rights under the Australian Consumer Law, known as consumer guarantees. These apply automatically and your policy cannot remove or shorten them.

Most confusing policies are confusing because they blur the two. Keep them in separate sections with separate headings.

One caution: this article describes the rules in general terms only. The ACCC publishes plain guidance for businesses on refunds, returns and consumer guarantees. Read it, and ask a legal adviser if your products are unusual or high value.

Change of mind: decide your offer and say it plainly

Since this part is up to you, treat it as a selling point. A generous, simple change of mind policy removes a big reason people hesitate, especially for clothing, shoes and gifts.

Decide each of these and write the answer down:

  • Time limit. How many days from delivery?
  • Condition. Unused, unwashed, with tags and original packaging?
  • What they get. A refund to the original payment method, an exchange or a store credit?
  • Return postage. Who pays? Customers accept paying for a change of mind return when they are told beforehand.
  • Exclusions. Sale items, custom orders, earrings, underwear, perishables and opened cosmetics are common ones.
  • Process. Who do they contact, and what do they send?

If you do not accept change of mind returns at all, that is allowed. Say so kindly and add the sentence that matters: this does not affect your rights if an item is faulty.

Faulty or not as described: rights you cannot sign away

For problems with the product itself, the consumer guarantees apply whatever your policy says. In broad terms, goods are expected to be of acceptable quality, to match their description and to be fit for their purpose. When they are not, the customer is entitled to a remedy, which may be a repair, a replacement or a refund depending on how serious the problem is.

A few practical points follow from this:

  • A blanket "no refunds" statement is a problem. So is "no refunds on sale items" if it suggests faulty sale items are excluded. Statements like these can mislead customers about their rights.
  • You are the customer's point of contact. Sending them off to deal with the manufacturer on their own is not the idea.
  • A short time limit in your policy does not cap these rights.

Your policy does not need to recite the law. It needs a clear statement that you honour it, and an easy way to get in touch.

Write the policy the way you would explain it at the counter. Compare these two versions of the same rule.

Hard to read: "Returns will only be accepted at the sole discretion of management subject to the terms herein and within the stipulated period."

Easy to read: "Changed your mind? Send it back within 30 days of delivery, unused and in its original packaging, and we will refund you."

Some habits that help:

  • Use "you" and "we"
  • Use headings that are questions customers ask: "What if my item arrives damaged?"
  • Give numbers. "30 days" is clear. "A reasonable period" is not.
  • Leave out threats, capital letters and anything you would not enforce

What a complete policy covers

Use this as a checklist when you draft yours.

  1. Change of mind returns: time limit, condition, exclusions and what the customer receives
  2. Who pays return postage for a change of mind
  3. Faulty, damaged or wrong items: how to report them, what to send (photos and an order number help), and a statement that consumer guarantees apply
  4. How to start a return, with a real email address or form
  5. Where to send the item
  6. How long a refund takes once you receive the return, and how it is paid
  7. A date showing when the policy was last updated

Put it where nervous buyers will see it

A policy hidden in the footer helps only the people who go looking. Bring the short version forward:

  • A one line summary on product pages, near the add to cart button
  • A link in the cart and at checkout
  • A line in the order confirmation email
  • The full policy in the footer of every page

Then make the experience match the words. If your policy says refunds take five business days, process them in three. A return handled quickly and politely is one of the cheapest ways to earn a second order, and often a kind review as well.

Your order