Foldwren

Subscriptions and memberships: recurring income online

What makes a good subscription or membership for a small business, how recurring billing is managed, and how to keep members once they have joined.

Recurring income is appealing for obvious reasons. Instead of starting each month at zero, you begin with a base of customers who have already said yes. A coffee roaster knows roughly how many bags to roast. A yoga studio knows the rent is covered.

The model only works, though, when the customer gets steady value from it. A subscription that people forget about and then resent is a slow way to lose goodwill. So the first question is whether what you sell suits one at all.

What suits a subscription

The strongest subscriptions fall into a handful of types.

  • Things that run out. Coffee beans, tea, pet food, skincare, cleaning refills, flowers for a reception desk. The customer would be reordering anyway, and you are saving them the bother.
  • Regular services. Lawn mowing, pool care, window cleaning, bookkeeping, a monthly dog groom. A set visit for a set fee.
  • Access. Gym and studio memberships, co-working desks, a members' area with courses or resources.
  • Curated selections. A wine club from a regional winery, a monthly book or craft box. The customer is paying for your taste and the pleasure of a surprise.
  • Priority and perks. A membership that gives discounts, early access or first pick of bookings. A physio clinic or beauty salon might bundle a monthly treatment with a member rate on extras.

A useful test: would the customer buy this again next month without being asked? If yes, a subscription saves them effort. If no, you are relying on them not noticing the charge, which is a poor foundation.

What does not suit one

Be honest about the poor fits. One off purchases dressed up as subscriptions, such as furniture or a wedding cake, are obvious. Less obvious are products people use slowly. If a tin of tea lasts ten weeks and you send one every four, the cupboard fills up and the cancellation follows.

Margins matter as well. Subscription discounts, postage on every delivery and payment fees add up. Work out what a typical subscriber is worth after all of that before you set a price.

Managing the billing

Recurring billing is handled by your payment provider or store platform. Stripe, PayPal and Shopify all support it, either directly or through add ons. The customer's card details are stored securely by the provider, not on your website, and the charge runs automatically on schedule.

What you need to decide and set up:

  • Frequency. Weekly, fortnightly, monthly, quarterly. Offering a choice reduces cancellations from people with too much product.
  • Minimum term. Whether there is one. We lean towards none, or a short one that is stated clearly.
  • Failed payments. Cards expire and get replaced all the time. Your system should retry and email the customer with a simple link to update their details. This quiet housekeeping saves members you would otherwise lose by accident.
  • Notice before charging. A short email a few days before each renewal, especially for annual plans. It prevents the "I forgot I had this" refund request.
  • Price changes. Give plenty of notice and explain why.

Be upfront on the sign up page about what is charged, how often, and how to cancel. Consumer law expects subscription terms to be clear and fair, and the ACCC has guidance on subscription practices. If you are unsure whether your terms pass, get advice.

Keeping members after month three

Signing people up is the easy half. The harder half is still being wanted in month six.

Things that help:

  • A strong start. The first delivery or visit sets the tone. Include a welcome note, explain how it all works and tell them how to make changes.
  • Flexibility. Let people skip a delivery, pause for a month, change the frequency or swap products themselves, without emailing you.
  • Variety. A rotating roast, a seasonal box, a new class on the timetable. Sameness is a quiet killer.
  • Communication that is not a bill. If the only email members get is a receipt, the relationship is purely a charge on a statement.
  • Ask. A short question after a few months ("Is the amount right for you?") catches problems before they become cancellations.

Offering to pause is the most useful of these. Many people who cancel do not dislike the product. They are travelling, short on cash that month or overstocked. A pause keeps them.

Make leaving easy

This sounds backwards, but it matters. Cancelling should take a couple of clicks in the customer's account. No phone call, no maze of screens, no guilt.

A hard exit does not keep customers. It turns them into people who dispute the charge with their bank and tell their friends. An easy exit, with an optional "what could we have done better?" and a pause offer, leaves the door open. Plenty of people come back to a subscription they left on good terms.

Test it with a small group first

Before building anything elaborate, run a pilot.

  1. Choose one subscription offer, not five.
  2. Invite twenty or thirty existing customers to join at a founding member price.
  3. Run it for three cycles and handle hiccups by hand.
  4. Ask each person what they would change.
  5. Check the real numbers: cost per delivery, time spent, how many stayed.
  6. Adjust the price, frequency or contents, then open it to everyone.

If your best customers are not interested, strangers will not be either, and you have learned that cheaply. If they are keen, you launch with a group of people who already believe in it.

Your order