Template or custom design: which is right for you?
An honest look at the trade offs between template and custom website design, where templates fall down and when one is completely fine.
For most small businesses starting out, a well chosen template is completely fine. Custom design earns its cost when your business has outgrown what a template can express, or when the website is central to how you make money. The trick is knowing which side of that line you are on.
There is a fair bit of snobbery about templates in the design trade, and a fair bit of overselling of custom work. Here is the plain version.
What the two terms actually mean
A template (sometimes called a theme) is a ready made design. The layout, fonts and page structures already exist. You or a designer add your logo, colours, words and photos. Platforms such as WordPress, Shopify and the various website builders all work this way by default.
A custom design starts from your business instead of from a pre made layout. A designer works out what your customers need, plans the pages around that, and designs each one for your content. Then it gets built to match.
In practice there is a wide middle ground. Many good small business sites start from a solid base and are customised heavily. The useful question is how much of the design was shaped around you.
The honest trade offs
Templates give you:
- A much lower cost up front
- A faster launch, sometimes within days
- A design that has already been tested on many screens
- Something you can see before you commit
Templates cost you:
- A look that other businesses share
- Layouts built for imaginary content, which your real content has to squeeze into
- Features and code you will never use, which can slow the site
- Limits you only discover when you want to change something
Custom design gives you:
- Pages planned around your customers' real questions
- A look that belongs to your brand alone
- Only the features you need, so the site can be leaner
- Room to grow in the direction your business is heading
Custom design costs you:
- More money and more weeks
- More of your own time for briefing and feedback
- A result that depends heavily on the skill of who you hire
Where templates fall down
The demo of a template always looks wonderful. It was built with professional photography, perfectly sized headlines and exactly three services with equally short names. The trouble starts when your own material goes in.
Your content doesn't fit the boxes
The template has room for a six word headline and yours needs twelve. It shows three services and you have seven. It expects wide, moody photos and you have phone pictures of finished decks. Each mismatch is small. Together they turn a polished demo into something that looks slightly off, and most people can't say why.
Everyone picked the same one
Popular templates are popular. If two other physio clinics in your town used the same one, your sites will look like siblings. For some businesses that doesn't matter. For others, standing apart is the whole point.
The edges are hard
Templates do what they were designed to do. Step outside that and things get difficult. You want the booking button in the header, a price calculator, or a different layout for one service page, and suddenly you are paying a developer to fight the template. A string of such workarounds can cost more than doing it properly would have.
When a template is completely fine
We would happily recommend a template in these situations:
- You are new and testing the idea. Don't spend heavily on design before you know the business has legs.
- Your needs are simple. A sole trader who needs five clear pages, a phone number and a contact form.
- Your budget is tight. A clean template with good words and real photos beats no site, and beats a half finished custom one.
- You need it quickly. A market stall that starts in two weeks, a new cafe opening next month.
- Your content suits it. If your material matches the template's layout without squeezing, the main objection disappears.
If you go this way, choose a simple, fast template over an impressive one. Strip out the sliders and effects. Spend your effort on what templates can't supply: clear wording, real photographs and an obvious next step on every page. A plain template with strong content will beat a fancy one with weak content every time.
When custom is worth the money
Custom design tends to pay off when:
- The website is a main source of leads or sales, so small improvements are worth real money.
- You are in a crowded market and looking like everyone else is a disadvantage.
- Your services are complex and need explaining in a particular order.
- You have an established brand that a template can only approximate.
- You have already outgrown a template and keep running into its limits.
Questions to ask before you decide
- How much of my new business comes through the website, or should?
- Could a stranger tell my site apart from my nearest competitor's?
- Do I have content that doesn't fit standard layouts?
- What will I need the site to do in two years that it doesn't need to do now?
- If I start with a template, how hard will it be to move to something custom later?
- Who owns the design and the content if I change providers?
If your answers are mostly "not much", "doesn't matter" and "nothing special", start with a template and put the savings into photography and good writing. If the website is where your customers decide whether to call you, that is the point where custom design starts paying for itself.