Foldwren

Web design trends worth ignoring

An opinionated list of web design fads that make small business websites harder to use, and the plain qualities that keep working instead.

Most web design trends are harmless, and a few are real improvements. But a handful make websites slower, more confusing or harder to read, and those are worth skipping no matter how many award winning sites use them.

This is an opinionated list. We have built some of these things at a client's request and watched them cause trouble, so consider it advice from people who have made the mistakes.

Design trends mostly start on portfolio sites, fashion labels and tech launches. Those sites are built to impress other designers and to be replaced within a year or two.

Your site has a different job. It needs to help a customer find your phone number, understand your services and trust you enough to get in touch. It probably needs to last several years. And your customers are not design enthusiasts. They are people with a blocked drain or a birthday cake to order, often on a phone, often in a hurry.

A trend that makes a site memorable to designers can make it baffling to a seventy year old looking for your opening hours.

The fads we would skip

Scroll effects that take over the page

You scroll down and the page does something else: it slides sideways, zooms into a photo, or locks in place while things animate. It is clever the first time and tiresome every time after. People expect scrolling to move the page at the speed their finger moves. Anything else feels broken, and on older phones it often stutters.

Autoplaying background video

A looping video behind the headline looks impressive in a presentation. On a real connection it slows the page, eats mobile data and pulls attention away from the words on top of it. If you have good footage, put it lower on the page with a play button.

Enormous headlines with tiny everything else

Huge type across the screen, followed by body text so small and pale you need to lean in. The headline says very little, and the information people came for is the hard part to read. Readable body text never goes out of fashion.

Hiding the menu on a desktop

Tucking the menu behind a three line icon makes sense on a phone, where space is tight. On a wide screen there is plenty of room, and hiding the menu just makes people click to discover what the site contains. Show the menu when there is room.

Loading screens and intro animations

A logo that spins or draws itself before you are allowed to see the site. This is a delay you have added on purpose. Visitors didn't come to admire the logo.

Custom cursors

Swapping the mouse pointer for a large circle or a trailing blob. It adds nothing, and it removes a tool people have known how to use all their lives.

Sliders and carousels

Rotating banners let a business avoid choosing its main message. Visitors see the first slide, if that, and the movement distracts from everything beneath it.

Layers of things on top of the page

A cookie notice, a chat bubble, a newsletter pop up and a sticky discount bar, all arriving within the first few seconds. Each seemed reasonable when it was added. Together they cover half a phone screen before the visitor has read a word.

Artificial pictures of people who don't exist

Generated images of a smiling "team" or happy "customers" are the new stock handshake, with an added problem: they suggest something about your business that isn't true. Real photos of real people, even plain ones, are worth far more.

What tends to last

Look at websites that have worked well for years and the same qualities keep appearing. None of them is exciting.

  • A plain headline that says what the business does and where.
  • Readable text. Good size, strong contrast, short paragraphs.
  • Speed. Pages that appear almost instantly, even on mobile data.
  • Real photographs of the actual work, people and place.
  • Obvious contact details on every page.
  • A simple, visible menu with labels anyone would understand.
  • Consistency. Buttons that look like buttons, links that look like links, the same layout from page to page.
  • Room to breathe. Enough space that each section can be taken in on its own.

Not everything new deserves suspicion. Designing for phones first, better accessibility, faster image formats and simpler layouts all started as trends and stayed because they made sites easier to use. That is the test that matters.

How to judge a trend for yourself

When a designer proposes something fashionable, or you see an effect you like on another site, run it past these questions.

  1. Does it help a customer do something, or is it there to impress?
  2. Does it slow the page? Ask to see it on an average phone using mobile data.
  3. Would my least technical customer understand it without any explanation?
  4. Does it still work with a keyboard, a screen reader, or motion effects turned off?
  5. Will it look dated in two years? Strong fashions age the fastest.
  6. What would we lose without it? If the honest answer is "nothing a customer would notice", leave it out.

Our view is that a small business site should aim to be clear, quick and recognisably yours. Put the personality into your photos, your wording and your colours, where it helps people remember you. Keep the mechanics of the site, the scrolling, the menu, the buttons, as ordinary as possible. Nobody has ever rung a plumber because the website had an interesting cursor.

Your order