Foldwren

Thinking about the return on a website

A simple way for small business owners to think about website value, track where enquiries come from and estimate the return with their own numbers.

A website is a business expense, and like any expense it should earn more than it costs. That sounds obvious, yet most small businesses never check. They pay for a site, hope it is working, and have no real idea either way.

You do not need a marketing degree or complicated software to work this out. You need your own numbers, a bit of honesty, and a habit of asking customers one question.

What counts as a return

The obvious return is new customers who found you through the site. But that is not the whole picture, and if you only count that, you will undervalue what the site does.

A website can pay its way in four ways:

  • New business. People who found you through a search and enquired.
  • Rescued business. People who heard about you elsewhere, checked the site, and went ahead because of what they saw. Without the site, some of them would have drifted off.
  • Better business. Enquiries that arrive already informed about your prices and services, so more of them convert and fewer waste your time.
  • Saved time. Questions the site answers so you do not have to. Bookings taken while you sleep. Forms that collect details you used to chase.

The first is easy to count. The others are real but fuzzier. Accept that from the start. You are after a sensible estimate, not an audited figure.

Know what a customer is worth

Before you can judge any marketing cost, you need one number that many owners have never worked out: what an average new customer is worth to you.

Work it out like this:

  1. Take your typical sale or job value.
  2. Multiply by how many times a typical customer buys from you over the time they stay.
  3. Take off the direct costs of doing that work, such as materials and labour.

What is left is roughly what a new customer contributes. For a wedding photographer, a customer usually buys once, so step two is one. For a dog groomer or a bookkeeper, a customer might come back every few weeks for years, so the lifetime figure is many times the first sale.

This matters because owners of repeat businesses often judge a website against the first sale only, and badly underestimate the return.

Track where enquiries come from

You cannot estimate return if you do not know which customers the website produced. Tracking does not have to be technical.

Ask every new customer

"How did you hear about us?" is the most useful question in small business marketing. Ask on the phone, add it to your enquiry form as a dropdown, and write the answers down. Follow up with "did you look at our website before getting in touch?" because many referred customers did.

Keep a simple tally

A notebook, a spreadsheet or a column in your job management system. For each new enquiry record the date, the source, and whether it became a paying customer.

After three months you will have something most small businesses never get: actual evidence.

A simple way to estimate it

Here is the sum, in words, using your own numbers.

  1. Add up what the site costs you in a year. Include the build if you paid upfront, spread over the years you expect to use it, plus hosting, maintenance and any time you spend on it yourself.
  2. Count the customers the site brought in over the year. Use your tally. Include people who searched and found you, and a fair share of referred people who say the site convinced them.
  3. Multiply that count by what a customer is worth, from the earlier section.
  4. Compare the two. If the value comfortably exceeds the cost, the site is paying its way.

There is an even simpler version, which we like for a first pass. Divide the yearly cost of the site by the worth of one customer. The result is the number of customers the site needs to bring in each year to break even. Then ask yourself whether that number looks easy, plausible or unlikely given what your tally shows.

What to do with the answer

Once you have three to six months of tracking, you will land in one of three places.

  • The site clearly pays for itself. Keep it maintained, and consider investing more in whatever is working: more service pages, better photos, more reviews.
  • It is roughly break even. Look for leaks. Are people visiting but not enquiring? Is the form too long? Is the phone number hard to find? Small fixes often shift the result.
  • It is not paying. Check the basics before giving up. Is the site visible in search for your service and area? Does it say clearly what you do? Is there an obvious next step? If all of that is in order and the result is still poor, your customers may come from somewhere else, and a small, low cost site is the right size for you.

Whichever applies, start the tally this week. It costs nothing, and you will finally be deciding with evidence instead of a hunch.

Your order