Website subscription or one off build: comparing the two
Compare paying upfront for a website with paying monthly, including what each model usually includes and which kind of business each one suits.
There are two main ways to pay a professional for a website. You can pay a larger sum once and own the result, or pay a smaller amount every month for a site that is built, hosted and looked after as a service. Both are legitimate. Both have been sold badly by someone. The right one depends on your cash flow, how hands on you want to be, and how long you expect to keep the site as it is.
Here is a fair comparison.
How each model works
The one off build
You agree on a scope and a price. The designer builds the site, you pay (often in stages), and it is handed over. After that, the running costs are yours to arrange: hosting, the domain, any software licences, and someone to do updates and fixes. Changes later are quoted separately or billed by the hour.
The subscription
You pay a monthly fee, sometimes with a setup cost and sometimes without. The fee covers the build plus the ongoing things: hosting, security, backups, updates and usually an allowance of changes. There is typically a minimum term. If you stop paying, the service stops.
The money, honestly compared
A one off build costs more at the start and less each month afterwards. A subscription costs little at the start and keeps costing.
Over a long enough period, the subscription will usually add up to more than the one off price. That is the obvious point, and it is where many comparisons stop. They should not, because the one off price is rarely the full cost of owning a site.
To compare properly, add up what a one off build really costs over, say, three or four years:
- The build itself
- Hosting and domain renewals
- Software and plugin licences
- Maintenance, either paid to someone or paid in your own time
- Content changes at an hourly rate
- Fixing things when they break
- A refresh, because a site built today will look its age eventually
Then compare that total with the subscription over the same period, using real quotes. Sometimes the one off still wins comfortably. Sometimes the gap is far smaller than expected.
There is also the cash flow question. A new cafe that has just paid for a fit out and a coffee machine may simply not have a lump sum to spare, however sensible it would be in the long run. A predictable monthly cost that sits beside the rent and the power bill can be easier to live with.
What is usually included, and what to check
Do not assume. Packages vary enormously in both models.
With a one off build, check:
- How many rounds of revisions are included before launch.
- Whether there is any support period after launch.
- Who arranges hosting and who is responsible for updates.
- What you receive at handover: files, logins, documentation.
With a subscription, check:
- The minimum term and what it costs to leave early.
- How many changes are included each month, and how a "change" is defined.
- What happens to the site, the content and the domain if you cancel.
- Whether the price is fixed or can rise.
In both cases, the domain name should be registered to your business. That is not negotiable.
Ownership and flexibility
This is the real trade off.
With a one off build, the site is yours. You can move it to another host, hire a different developer, or leave it untouched for years. That freedom comes with responsibility. If nobody is looking after it, nobody is looking after it.
With a subscription, you are generally paying for a service, not buying an asset. If you leave, you usually keep your content and your domain, and the site itself stays behind. In return, somebody else carries the responsibility for keeping it running, and the incentive to keep you happy does not end at launch.
Who each one suits
A one off build tends to suit you if:
- You have the budget available now and prefer to own things outright.
- You have someone, in house or on call, who will handle maintenance.
- Your site is complex or unusual and needs a custom scope.
- You want complete freedom to move or modify it later.
A subscription tends to suit you if:
- You would rather spread the cost than pay a lump sum.
- You want one point of contact for everything and no technical chores.
- Your site is fairly standard: services, about, gallery, contact, perhaps bookings.
- You know you will want regular small changes.
A builder with an established business, cash in the bank and a nephew who works in IT might well choose a one off build. A dog groomer in her first year who wants to be found online and never think about plugins will probably be happier on a subscription.
Questions to ask before choosing
- What will this cost me in total over three years, including everything?
- Who is responsible for updates, backups and security after launch?
- If something breaks on a weekend, who fixes it and what does that cost?
- If I want to leave, what do I take with me?
- Is the domain in my name?
- What happens when the site needs a refresh?
Put those questions to both kinds of provider and compare the answers side by side. The better choice for your business usually becomes obvious once the full picture is on the table.