A website or a Facebook page: why not just social media?
What social media does well for a small business, what you do not control on it, and how a website and your social pages should work together.
A Facebook or Instagram page is free, quick to set up, and half your customers are already there. So it is a fair question why you would pay for a website as well. Our answer is that they do different jobs, and social is the one you do not control.
That does not mean social is a waste of time. For some businesses it is the best marketing they have. It just should not be the only thing holding you up.
What social media is good for
Credit where it is due. Social platforms are very good at a few things:
- Staying in front of people who already know you. A cafe posting the weekend special, a florist showing this morning's bunches, a dog groomer posting a freshly clipped cavoodle. Regulars see it and remember you exist.
- Showing personality. Short videos and casual photos let people see who is behind the counter.
- Quick conversation. Comments and messages are low effort for customers.
- Local reach. Community groups and shares can spread the word around a suburb fast.
If you enjoy it and it brings people in, keep going.
What you do not control
Here is the catch. A social page is a room you are renting, and the landlord can rearrange the furniture whenever they like.
Who sees your posts
You might have a few thousand followers, but the platform decides how many of them see each post. That share has a habit of shrinking over time unless you pay to boost it. You built the audience, but you do not get to reach it on your own terms.
What the page looks like and what sits beside it
You cannot choose the layout. You cannot stop ads, suggested pages or a competitor's post appearing right next to yours. You cannot decide that your price list or your booking button goes first.
Whether the account exists tomorrow
Accounts get hacked, locked or suspended, sometimes by mistake, and getting a human to help can take a long time. If that page is your only presence, your business disappears from the internet until it is sorted.
Who can see it at all
Not everyone has an account, and some platforms nag visitors to log in before showing much. A potential customer who is not on that platform may simply give up.
How findable the information is
Try finding a business's opening hours over Easter by scrolling their feed. Posts are sorted by date, not by usefulness. The answer to a simple question could be three months down the page.
What a website does better
A website is organised around what the visitor wants to know, not around what you posted last.
- Services, prices, hours and contact details sit in fixed, predictable places.
- It can show up in search for the things you do, including for people who have never heard of you.
- You own the address. If you change who builds or hosts the site, the domain comes with you.
- You can add things platforms do not offer well: a proper booking system, a detailed quote form, an online shop, a page per service.
- It looks the same next year as it does today, unless you choose to change it.
It also signals something. Rightly or wrongly, plenty of people read "Facebook page only" as "side hustle" and a proper site with a matching email address as "real business".
How the two work together
The best setup is not one or the other. Think of the website as the shop and social as the footpath outside it.
Say you run a florist. Here is how it might work:
- You post a photo of this week's seasonal bunch on Instagram.
- The caption says "order by Thursday for weekend delivery" and points to your site.
- The link in your profile goes to the order page, where the customer picks a size, a delivery date and pays.
- On the confirmation page, you invite them to join your email list for Mother's Day reminders.
Social got the attention. The website took the order and collected a contact detail that belongs to you. Next time, you can email that customer directly without hoping a platform shows them your post.
A few habits make this work:
- Put your website address in every profile.
- Send people to a specific page instead of the home page.
- Keep hours, phone number and address identical everywhere.
- Treat social posts as temporary and the website as the permanent record. If something matters for more than a week, it goes on the site.
What we would do if you are starting from scratch
If you have neither, we would get a simple website up first, claim your Google Business Profile, then pick one social platform that suits your business and do it properly. One well kept page beats four neglected ones.
If you already have a busy social page and no site, do not abandon it. Start by writing down the questions people ask in your messages and comments. Those questions are the outline for your website. Then build a small site that answers them, and begin pointing your posts there.
A quick test to finish. Imagine your main social account was locked for a month from tomorrow. Would new customers still be able to find you, see what you offer and get in touch? If not, that is the gap a website fills.