Abandoned carts: why they happen and what to do
Why shoppers leave items in the cart without buying, which fixes to try first, and how to send reminder emails that help without being pushy.
Every online store has abandoned carts, and plenty of them. People add things, wander off, and never come back. Some of that is completely normal behaviour and nothing to lose sleep over. Some of it is your store putting obstacles in the way, and that part you can fix.
The useful skill is telling the two apart.
Not every abandoned cart was a sale
A lot of shoppers use the cart as a notepad. They are comparing three shops, checking what postage would come to, saving something for payday, or planning to show a partner later. A parent gets interrupted. A phone battery dies on the train.
None of those people were lost because of anything you did, and some of them will return on their own. So do not treat your abandonment figure as a scoreboard of failure, and be sceptical of anyone quoting a "normal" rate at you. Stores vary enormously by product, price and audience. The only comparison that means much is your own store this month against your own store last month.
The causes you can do something about
These are the reasons that come up again and again, and they are all within your control.
- Surprise costs. Shipping, fees or surcharges that appear only at the last step.
- Forced account creation. Asking a first time buyer to register before paying.
- A long or fiddly form. Too many fields, or errors that wipe what was typed.
- Unclear delivery times. The customer needs it by Friday and cannot tell if it will arrive.
- Doubts about the shop. No returns policy in sight, no contact details, a checkout that looks different from the rest of the site.
- A missing payment method. Some people will only pay with PayPal or a digital wallet.
- Technical trouble. A slow page, a payment that fails, a button that does not respond on certain phones.
- Late bad news. The item is unavailable, or you do not deliver to their postcode, and they only find out at the final step.
Fixes, in the order we would try them
Start with what is cheap and likely, then work up.
- Go through the checkout yourself on a phone. Use mobile data, not the office wifi. Note every point of friction. This takes fifteen minutes and usually finds something.
- Show shipping costs earlier. Put them on product pages and in the cart. If postage varies, add a postcode estimator.
- Turn on guest checkout. If your platform allows it and you have it switched off, switch it on.
- Cut fields. Remove anything that is not needed to deliver the order.
- Add a delivery estimate. "Dispatched within two business days" near the button answers the Friday question.
- Add one more payment option. If you only take cards, a wallet or PayPal is often the next most useful.
- Link your returns policy from the cart and checkout. One short line is enough.
- Check your failed payments. Your payment provider's dashboard will show declined and incomplete payments. A cluster of failures can point to a setup problem.
Make one or two changes at a time and give them a few weeks. If you change six things at once, you will not know which one helped.
Reminder emails, done politely
Most store platforms, Shopify included, can send an automatic email to someone who entered their email address at checkout and then left. Used with a light touch, these are helpful. Plenty of people simply got distracted and appreciate the nudge.
What a good reminder looks like:
- Sent a few hours to a day after the cart was left, not within minutes
- A plain subject line, such as "You left something in your cart"
- A photo and name of the item, and a button straight back to the saved cart
- A line offering help: "Any questions about sizing or delivery? Reply to this email"
- Written in the same voice as your shop
What we would avoid:
- A long chain of emails. One reminder is polite. A second a few days later is the limit. Five is pestering.
- An automatic discount every time. Customers learn quickly that leaving a cart earns ten per cent off, and you end up training your best buyers to wait.
- Fake urgency. "Only 1 left!" when there are forty in the storeroom is misleading, and people can tell.
- Guilt. "Did we do something wrong?" is not the tone for a shop.
A word on permission. Marketing emails in Australia are covered by spam rules about consent and unsubscribing. How those apply to cart reminders depends on the detail, so check the guidance from the ACMA, include an unsubscribe link, and do not quietly add those addresses to your newsletter list.
The replies are the real prize
Invite people to reply to the reminder, and read every answer. "I wasn't sure it would fit" tells you the size guide is missing. "Postage was more than the item" tells you about your shipping rates. These are free, specific notes from people who nearly bought.
Keep a simple list of the reasons you hear. After a couple of months a pattern appears, and it is usually one or two things.
What to do this week
Pick the cheapest test first. Tonight, buy something from your own store on your phone and write down every moment you hesitated. Tomorrow, fix the easiest one. Then switch on a single, friendly reminder email and watch the replies. That combination handles most of the fixable part, and the rest is people being people.