Marketplaces or your own store: where to sell
The trade-offs between selling on a marketplace and running your own online store, covering reach, control, fees and how to use both together.
New online sellers nearly always ask whether to sell on a marketplace such as eBay, Etsy or Amazon, or through their own website. For most small businesses we would say both, in the right order, for different jobs.
The two are not really competitors. A marketplace is a stall in someone else's very busy shopping centre. Your own store is your own shopfront on a quieter street. Each has a place, and the choice depends on what you sell and what you want the business to become.
What a marketplace gives you
The big advantage is people. Shoppers are already there, card in hand, searching for products like yours. You do not have to work out how to bring them in.
- A ready audience. Buyers search the marketplace directly, often before they search anywhere else.
- Borrowed trust. People who would hesitate at an unknown website will buy from an unknown seller on a platform they know, because the platform stands behind the sale.
- Speed. You can list a product in an afternoon. Payments, checkout and often shipping labels are handled for you.
- A cheap test. You can find out whether anyone wants the product before investing in a full store.
What a marketplace costs you
You pay for that reach in money and in control.
Fees. Marketplaces charge in several ways: listing fees, a commission on each sale, payment processing, and optional advertising to appear higher in results. Each one may look small. Together they can take a serious share of the sale price. Structures differ between platforms and change over time, so read the current fee schedule and run the numbers on your own products before you list.
Competition on the same page. Your product appears beside dozens of similar ones, sorted mostly by price and rating. Shoppers compare at a glance, which pushes prices down. If someone else is selling the identical item, the cheapest usually wins.
The customer is not yours. The buyer thinks "I bought it on the marketplace", not "I bought it from you". You typically get limited contact details and are restricted in how you may contact buyers afterwards, so building a mailing list or repeat custom is difficult.
Rules you did not write. The platform decides how listings look, how disputes are settled, what you can sell and where you rank. Policies change, and an account can be suspended while a complaint is sorted out. A business with every sale on one platform is exposed to decisions it has no say in.
What your own store gives you
Your own website flips most of those points.
- Your brand, your way. The design, photos, story and tone are yours. Nobody else's products sit beside yours.
- The customer relationship. You can invite buyers to your email list, send them news of new stock and bring them back without paying a commission each time.
- Better margin per sale. You still pay payment fees and the cost of running the site, but there is no marketplace commission on top.
- Flexibility. Bundles, subscriptions, gift vouchers, click and collect, wholesale pricing, pre-orders. You decide what the store does.
- An asset. A website with its own traffic, mailing list and reputation is something you own. A marketplace seller rating is on loan.
The honest downside of going it alone
A new store has no visitors. None. Building it is the smaller part of the job. Bringing people to it is the larger one.
Traffic comes from search, social media, email, advertising, word of mouth and your physical customers, and all of those take time or money. A business with an existing following, a shopfront or a market stall has a head start. A business starting from nothing should expect a slow first few months.
Using both without doubling the work
For many small sellers, the sensible approach is to treat the marketplace as a way to be discovered and your own store as home.
- Keep stock in sync. If you have ten of an item, both channels need to know when one sells. Many store platforms, including Shopify, can connect to major marketplaces and manage this. Without syncing, you will oversell.
- Choose what goes where. Put your most searchable, competitive lines on the marketplace. Keep limited editions, bundles and your full range on your own site.
- Give people a reason to come direct. A wider range, a loyalty perk, early access to new releases, or simply better service.
- Price with care. Some platforms have conditions about pricing elsewhere, so read the seller terms before setting different prices on different channels.
- Watch the numbers separately. Know your profit per order on each channel after fees, rather than only the sales total.
Which to start with
Here is how we would decide.
Start on a marketplace if you have no audience yet, your product is something people search for by type (vintage lamps, phone cases, handmade earrings), and you want to test demand quickly.
Start with your own store if you already have customers through a shop, a market stall, social media or a trade, your product is distinctive, or your margins cannot carry a commission.
Plan for both if you are in it for the long run. Even while the marketplace does most of the selling, register your domain name, set up a simple site and start an email list. The aim over time is for a growing share of sales to come through the channel you control.