Foldwren

How to tell whether your SEO is working

Learn how to judge whether SEO is working by tracking enquiries first, reading Search Console basics, and ignoring the numbers that mislead.

The simplest test of SEO is whether more of the right people are contacting you. Rankings, traffic and scores are all stepping stones toward that, and it is easy to get lost admiring the stepping stones.

Here is what we would measure, what to look at each month, and what to stop worrying about.

Start with enquiries

You are doing SEO to get customers. So count the things that lead to customers.

  • Phone calls
  • Contact form submissions
  • Online bookings and quote requests
  • Direction requests and calls from your business profile
  • Online sales, if you sell that way

Then find out where they came from. The low tech method is the best one: ask. "How did you find us?" on your enquiry form and at the counter gives you information no software can. Keep a simple tally.

If enquiries from search are growing and they are the kind of jobs you want, your SEO is working, whatever any ranking report says. If rankings are up but the phone is no busier, something in between is broken, and that is worth knowing too.

What does Google Search Console tell you?

Search Console is a free tool from Google that shows how your site performs in its search results. It is the most trustworthy source you have, because it comes from the search engine itself. If it is not set up, do that first.

The performance report has four main numbers.

  • Clicks: how many times someone clicked through to your site from search.
  • Impressions: how many times a page of yours was shown in results, whether or not anyone clicked.
  • Click through rate: clicks divided by impressions. A low rate on a page that is shown often may mean the title and description need work.
  • Average position: roughly where your pages appeared, averaged across all searches. Treat it as a trend, not a precise ranking.

More useful than the totals are the two lists beneath them.

Queries shows the actual searches that brought up your site. This is where you find out what people really type, which is often not what you expected.

Pages shows which of your pages earn the clicks. It tells you what is pulling its weight and what is not.

Elsewhere in the tool, the indexing report shows which pages Google has included and which it has not, with reasons. If an important page is missing, that needs fixing before anything else matters.

What should you look at each month?

Monthly is often enough. Compare with the previous month, and with the same month a year earlier if your trade is seasonal.

  1. Total clicks and impressions: are they trending up over several months?
  2. Top queries: are they relevant to what you sell? Any new ones worth a dedicated page?
  3. Queries with plenty of impressions but few clicks: can the title or description be improved?
  4. Top pages: are your main service pages among them?
  5. Indexing: are any important pages excluded or showing errors?
  6. Enquiries: how many, from where, and were they good ones?

Look for direction over three to six months. Single months jump around for all sorts of reasons, including the weather and school holidays.

What should you ignore?

A lot of what gets reported is noise.

  • Daily ranking changes. Positions move constantly. Checking daily tells you nothing and costs you sleep.
  • What you see when you search yourself. Results are influenced by your location and other factors, so your own view may differ from a customer's a few suburbs away.
  • Ranking first for your own business name. Nice, but it is the bare minimum.
  • Ranking for phrases nobody searches. Being number one for a long, odd phrase only you would type is not an achievement.
  • Third party authority scores. Various tools give sites a score out of 100. These are the tool makers' own estimates, not something search engines use.
  • Raw visitor numbers on their own. A thousand visitors from outside your service area are worth less than twenty from inside it.
  • Time on page, in isolation. Someone who lands, finds your phone number and rings you has left in ten seconds. That is a success.

A simple monthly scorecard

You can keep this in a spreadsheet or on paper. One row a month.

  1. Enquiries from all sources
  2. Enquiries where the person said they found you through search
  3. Search Console clicks
  4. Search Console impressions
  5. Calls and direction requests from your business profile
  6. Number of reviews and average rating
  7. One line on what was done that month: pages added, fixes made

After six months you will have a clear picture of whether the effort is paying off, and which work seemed to move things.

When should you be concerned?

  • Clicks and impressions have been flat or falling for several months while work has been going on
  • There is a sudden sharp drop, which may point to a technical problem or a site change gone wrong
  • Traffic is rising but enquiries are not, which suggests the wrong visitors or a site that does not convert them
  • Your provider reports rankings but cannot connect them to enquiries

None of these is a catastrophe. Each is a prompt to ask a specific question. If you pay someone for SEO, bring the scorecard to your next conversation and ask them to explain it in terms of customers. A good one will be glad you asked.

Your order