Keeping your rankings when you redesign your website
Learn how to protect your search rankings during a website redesign with a baseline, a redirect map, careful content choices and launch checks.
A redesign is the riskiest moment for a website's search visibility. A site that has ranked steadily for years can lose much of its traffic in a week, and the cause is almost never the new look. It is what got lost in the move.
The risks are well understood, and with some planning they are avoidable.
Why do redesigns lose rankings?
Search engines know your site as a set of specific addresses, each with content and a history. A redesign can disturb all three.
- Addresses change. The old page lived at one address and the new one lives at another. Without a redirect, the old address shows an error, and everything that page had earned is thrown away.
- Content disappears. A cleaner design often means fewer words. Pages that ranked because they answered questions thoroughly are cut down to a headline and a photo.
- Pages are merged or dropped. Five service pages become one. The searches those five answered now have nowhere to land.
- Technical details are missed. Page titles are reset to defaults, or the "hide from search engines" setting used during building is left on.
Each of these is preventable. They happen when a redesign is treated as a visual project only.
What should you record before you start?
Take stock of the current site while it is still live. This is your baseline.
- List every page address. Your sitemap or website editor can produce this. Include blog posts and PDFs.
- Find out which pages bring search visitors. Google Search Console shows the pages that get the most clicks and the searches behind them. These are the ones to protect.
- Note which pages have links from other sites. Search Console's links report shows this.
- Save the existing titles and descriptions for each important page.
- Take a copy of the content. Save the text of your key pages somewhere safe.
- Record your current numbers. Clicks, impressions and enquiries for the past few months, so you can compare afterwards.
This takes an hour or two and it is the most valuable part of the process.
How do redirects work?
A redirect tells browsers and search engines that a page has moved permanently to a new address. Anyone visiting the old one is sent to the new one automatically. Search engines, over time, transfer what they knew about the old page to the new one.
You need a redirect map: a simple two column list with each old address beside its new equivalent.
Rules we follow:
- Keep addresses the same wherever possible. If the page is not moving, nothing can go wrong with it.
- Where an address must change, redirect to the closest matching page instead of the home page.
- Redirect every old address that had visitors or links, including old blog posts.
- Use permanent redirects (often called 301s), not temporary ones.
- Avoid chains, where one redirect leads to another and then another.
Say a builder's old site had pages at addresses ending in /kitchen-renovations and /bathroom-renovations, and the new site uses /services/kitchens and /services/bathrooms. Each old address should redirect to its matching new one. Sending both to the home page would waste them.
How do you keep the content that works?
Before anything is cut, check it against your baseline. If a page brings in search visitors, treat its content with care.
- Keep the substance. Tidy the wording and improve the layout, but keep the topics, questions and details the page covers.
- Do not trade text for looks. If the design calls for less text on screen, use sections that expand, or move detail further down the page. Do not delete it.
- Be cautious about merging. Combining weak, overlapping pages is fine. Combining distinct service pages that each rank is usually a mistake.
- Carry over titles, descriptions and headings for the pages that perform, or improve them deliberately.
A redesign is also a chance to improve content, and you should take it. Just add before you subtract.
What should you check on launch day?
Launches are busy and things get missed. Work from a list.
- The setting that hides the site from search engines is off
- Every address in the redirect map goes to the right place (test them, do not assume)
- Each important page has its proper title and description
- The sitemap reflects the new site and has been submitted in Search Console
- Analytics and Search Console are working on the new site
- Forms send, phone numbers can be tapped, booking tools work
- The site is fast and usable on a phone
- Your business profile and main directory listings point to working pages
What should you watch afterwards?
Some movement after a redesign is normal. Search engines need to revisit everything, and rankings can wobble for a few weeks before settling.
For the first month or two:
- Check Search Console weekly for pages reported as not found, and add redirects for any you missed.
- Compare clicks and impressions for your key pages against the baseline.
- Watch enquiry numbers.
- Search for your main services yourself and click through to check where you land.
A modest dip that recovers is nothing to worry about. A sharp fall that does not recover within a few weeks points to something specific, usually missing redirects, removed content or blocked pages. With a good baseline you can find it quickly, which is the whole reason for making one.