Online reviews and how they affect local rankings
Understand in general terms how reviews relate to local search visibility, how to ask for them properly, and how to reply to good and bad ones.
Reviews do two jobs. They help persuade a person who has found you to choose you, and they appear to play a part in whether you are found in local results at all.
On the second point we need to be careful. Google has said in general terms that review count and rating are among the things that feed into how prominent a business is locally. It has not said how much they count, and no one outside the company knows. What we can say with confidence is that a healthy, steady set of genuine reviews makes a business easier to choose, and seems to make it easier to find.
How do reviews relate to local rankings?
Local results are described as depending on relevance, distance and prominence. Reviews sit under prominence, alongside things such as links, mentions and how well known a business is.
A few sensible observations, without pretending to precision:
- Quantity and rating both seem to matter, though a perfect score is not required and can even look odd.
- Freshness appears to help. A stream of new reviews suggests an active business. Fifty reviews that all stopped three years ago suggest less.
- The words matter to readers, and may help with relevance. When customers naturally mention the service they received, it reinforces what you do.
- Replies show engagement. Whether or not they affect ranking directly, they affect people.
Even if reviews had no bearing on ranking, they would be worth the effort. When three businesses appear on the map, the stars and the number beside them are often the first thing people look at.
How do you ask for reviews?
Most happy customers will leave one if asked. Very few will without being asked. So ask.
- Pick the right moment. Straight after a good result: the job is finished, the dog looks great, the client has just thanked you.
- Ask personally. A request from the person who did the work beats any automated message.
- Make it one tap. Your business profile provides a direct link to the review form. Send it by text or email, or put it on a card or a QR code at the counter.
- Follow up once. A short reminder a few days later is fine. More than that is nagging.
- Ask everyone. Make it part of how every job finishes, so reviews arrive steadily.
What are the rules?
Review platforms have policies, and Australian consumer law has things to say about misleading reviews as well. In general terms:
- Reviews should come from real customers describing real experiences
- You should not write reviews for your own business or have staff or family pose as customers
- You should not pay for reviews or offer rewards on the condition that the review is positive
- You should not invite only your happy customers while steering unhappy ones elsewhere
- You should not post negative reviews about competitors
Policies differ between platforms, and incentives in particular are an area where some platforms are strict. Check the current policy of the platform you are using, and read the consumer regulator's guidance on online reviews if you are unsure.
Apart from the rules, fake reviews tend to be obvious. Ten glowing five star reviews in one week from accounts with no history fool nobody.
How should you reply?
Reply to all of them. It takes a minute each, and the reply is read by far more people than the reviewer.
Positive reviews
Thank the person, mention something specific, keep it short. Something like: Thanks, Sam. Glad the new deck was ready in time for the party. Enjoy it. Avoid pasting the same reply under every review.
Negative reviews
These matter most. A calm reply to a bad review can do more for your reputation than five good ones.
- Wait until you are not angry
- Acknowledge the problem and apologise where it is warranted
- Briefly say what you have done or will do
- Invite them to contact you directly to sort it out
- Do not argue, and do not share private details about them or the job
An example of the tone: I'm sorry we arrived later than booked and that nobody called ahead. That is not good enough, and we have changed how we confirm arrival times. Please ring the office so I can make this right.
Future customers do not expect perfection. They want to see how you behave when something goes wrong.
Fake or abusive reviews
If a review is clearly not from a customer, or breaks the platform's rules, you can report it through your profile. Removal is not guaranteed and can be slow. A brief, polite public reply noting that you have no record of the person as a customer is reasonable in the meantime.
A simple review routine
- Save your direct review link where every staff member can find it
- Ask at the end of every job or visit
- Send the link the same day
- Check for new reviews weekly
- Reply to each within a few days
- Raise recurring complaints with your team and fix the cause
- Once a quarter, read your last twenty reviews as a stranger would
That last step is the useful one. Reviews are free customer research. If three people mention that you were hard to reach by phone, that is worth more than any ranking advice we could give you.