Seven signs it is time to redesign your website
Seven practical signs your website needs work, how to choose between a refresh and a full rebuild, and what is worth keeping either way.
A website needs redesigning when it has stopped doing its job, and age alone doesn't tell you that. Some eight year old sites still bring in steady work. Some two year old sites were never right. The question to ask is whether the site still helps customers find you, trust you and get in touch.
Here are the signs we look for, followed by how to decide between a light refresh and a full rebuild.
The seven signs
1. It is awkward on a phone
If visitors have to pinch, zoom or scroll sideways, or if buttons are too small to tap, this is the most urgent sign on the list. Most of your visitors are likely on phones, and they won't persist.
2. You are a bit embarrassed to share it
When you hand over a business card and find yourself saying "the website's a bit out of date, just give me a call", listen to that instinct. If you hesitate to send people there, it is costing you.
3. The business has changed and the site hasn't
You have dropped services, added new ones, moved premises or shifted to a different kind of customer. The site still describes the business you ran five years ago. A dog groomer who now mostly does mobile grooming shouldn't have a homepage about the old salon.
4. You can't update it yourself
Changing your opening hours means emailing someone who takes a fortnight, or logging into a system nobody remembers the password for. A site that can't be kept current will slowly fill up with wrong information.
5. It is slow
Pages that take several seconds to appear lose people before they see anything. Slowness often comes from oversized images, old plugins or cheap hosting. Sometimes it can be fixed without a redesign, so get it checked before assuming the worst.
6. Enquiries have dried up or are the wrong kind
If the phone used to ring from the website and now it doesn't, or the enquiries you get are for work you don't want, the site is sending the wrong message. Check your analytics as well, since a drop in visits is a different problem from a drop in enquiries.
7. Things are broken or flagged as unsafe
Forms that don't send, missing images, a browser warning that the site is "not secure", booking links that go nowhere. Any one of these tells a visitor the business may not be paying attention.
One sign is a reason to make a fix. Three or more usually means the site needs proper attention.
Refresh or rebuild?
Not every tired site needs to be torn down. Think of it like a house: sometimes you repaint and replace the kitchen benchtop, and sometimes the stumps are gone.
A refresh is usually enough when:
- The site works well on phones and loads quickly.
- The structure and page list still match the business.
- You can edit content without help.
- The main complaints are about looks: dated photos, tired colours, old wording.
A refresh might cover new photography, rewritten headlines, an updated colour palette, a tidier homepage and clearer buttons. It is quicker and cheaper, and often delivers most of the benefit.
A rebuild makes more sense when:
- The site isn't mobile friendly and can't be made so without redoing the layout.
- The platform it runs on is outdated, unsupported or painful to manage.
- The business has changed so much that the structure no longer fits.
- You need something it can't do, such as online booking or selling products.
- Patches have piled up to the point where every small change breaks something else.
Our honest view: if the foundations are sound, refresh. If you are fighting the foundations, rebuild. Spending money to decorate a site that is broken underneath is the one option we would steer you away from.
What to keep
A redesign shouldn't mean throwing everything out. Some parts of your current site have value that is easy to destroy by accident.
- Pages that bring in search visitors. Check which pages people land on from Google. Keep their content, and if their addresses change, have each old address redirected to the new one. Skipping this is the most common way a redesign damages search rankings.
- Your domain name. Keep the one you have unless there is a strong reason to change. Make sure the registration is in your name, too.
- Wording that works. If a particular service description reliably prompts enquiries, carry it over.
- Reviews and testimonials. With permission already given, these are hard won.
- Good photos of real work. Even if the layout around them changes.
- Analytics history. Keep the same account running so you can compare before and after.
What to do before you talk to a designer
A bit of preparation makes any redesign conversation shorter and cheaper.
- Look at your site on a phone and write down everything that annoys you.
- List what has changed in the business since the site was built.
- Check your analytics for the most visited pages and where visitors come from.
- Ask three customers what they looked for on your site and whether they found it.
- Note two or three websites you find easy to use, and what you like about each.
- Decide the one thing you most want the new site to achieve, such as more quote requests or fewer phone calls about opening hours.
Bring that list to the first meeting. It turns "we need a new website" into a clear problem with a clear measure of success, and it will quickly show whether a refresh will do or a rebuild is the smarter spend.